Hang-OutCalendarHomeFAQSearchMemberlistUsergroupsRegisterLog in

Share | 
 

 MW3 vs Battlefield 3

View previous topic View next topic Go down 

MW3 or Battlefield 3?
MW3 all the way!
13%
 13% [ 2 ]
Battlefield 3 dominates COD!
31%
 31% [ 5 ]
Honestly, I don't care. I just want to have fun.
56%
 56% [ 9 ]
Total Votes : 16
 

AuthorMessage
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 3:10 am

( I'm sure there's probably been a topic on here about this before. This topic is just to show opinions. Please be mature about this, don't start arguments over video games. )

If you don't know what they are, they're games that were released around the same time. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 and Battlefield 3. They're released on the PS3, XBOX360 and PC. I would like to here your opinions about both of these games and why you think one is better than the other.

Point Streaks in this game are amazing. They actually reward you for helping your team. Specialist is genius as well. MW3 has an extremely bad spawn system and a lot of OP guns that will just rape you in one shot. (aka Type 95) Everyone camps with akimbo FMGs. The maps are horrible. Infinity Ward says they "listen to the community". If they listened to the community then they would put the stuff people actually wanted in the game and take out the stuff they didn't want. Any noob in this game can come on a rape face. The game is just way too noob friendly. Easily the worst COD ever made. I don't even know how this crap is shooter of the year.

3/10

Battlefield 3 is realistic enough to satisfy me. The rank up system in that game takes actual time to increase your level. Explosives actually make things explode. So far I see nothing OP in it. ( I'm sure there probably is. ) It just takes more skill and practice to become good at the game. A noob can't just buy the game a dominate.

8/10

Well that's it for me. Tell me what you guys think about these two games!


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
AsianShadow
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 13
Posts : 1467
Reputation : 1711
Waifu : ProdigyShadow

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 7:56 am

Both MW3 and Battlefield 3 are great games but I must agree what you said about MW3 being noob friendly is true,but I dont really care what shooting game I play,mostly for me all I care about is the grahics and "plot".


~Those who never fail are those who never try.~


Spoiler:
 
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:01 am

I don't really play the Campaign too much. Usually when I'm bored i'll play through it one time just to see how it is. MW3's graphics haven't really improved from MW2 at all. I still think MW2's graphics are better. :/ Battlefield 3's graphics are far superior to MW3's any day.


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Kimo Force
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
avatar

Achievement Points : 9
Posts : 3046
Reputation : 3745
Waifu : Kimo Force

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:08 am

Modern Warfare 3 is the same thing over and over again, just worse. Though I never really played Battlefield, I know that Three was a whole new experience compared to the previous versions because I have seen the gameplay for each. You don't need to play Battlefield 3 to decide, it's the clear winner here.



EW: also wtf does SJW stand for? Stupid Jealous Woman?
Ryuuji Takasu: looks cute. but cute sounds girly. so ill say kawaii
Lesbihonest: damn kimo you have the sexiest male voice ive ever heard o.o
Rika Furude: no, that wasnt ripped from the Bible or something, it's one of Rika Furude's poems in Higurashi. Deep ****.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:10 am

Call of Duty 4 is Infinity Ward's only descent creation. If you've ever played it that is.


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Silver
Natura Wild-Boy
Natura Wild-Boy
avatar

Achievement Points : 38
Posts : 830
Reputation : 1047
Waifu : Forgot

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:11 am

skyrim :3
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:16 am

A little off topic, but I guess I can comment on Skyrim as well.

Skyrim is amazing. nuff said


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fish
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 3054
Reputation : 3329
Waifu : Meheheh

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:22 am

CoD games are generally terrible. CoD4 was good, yeah. Then it's just new maps with new guns under the facade of a new game name.

Good points:
Same thing everybody liked in CoD4
Graphics are alright
Easy-to-use
Vaguely good customisation

Bad points:
Same thing in MW1 and MW2.
Become overused and tacky
Various annoying inaccuracies (e.g. Shotguns having retardedly small range)
Various general stupidities (knife uselessness, mini-robots, etc.)
REALLY stupid health regeneration
Really stupid amount of damage you can take before you die


BF3 is actually, overall, quite a good game, but there are some bad points.

Good points:
Shotgun realism
Realistic sound effects
Realistic effects (like going prone, grenades, etc.)
Takes less to kill people (again, realism)
More interesting weapons
Ability to use vehicles
Way bigger maps
Flexibility
Better melee kills

Bad points:
Easier to die
Generally alot of running
Retarded team spawn system is retarded.
Aircraft are REALLY hard to use. No joke.
Health regeneration system (bleck.)

Over all I prefer BF3.











❑ Single
❑ Taken
✔ Mentally dating a character that doesn't actually exist.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Katarina
Archfiend Empress
 Archfiend Empress
avatar

Achievement Points : 58
Posts : 1189
Reputation : 1435
Waifu : Prinzessin Kitty

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:33 am

Mw3 all the way, i love perks




Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fish
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 3054
Reputation : 3329
Waifu : Meheheh

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:40 am

BF3 also has perks, have you actually played BF3? xD











❑ Single
❑ Taken
✔ Mentally dating a character that doesn't actually exist.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Kimo Force
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
avatar

Achievement Points : 9
Posts : 3046
Reputation : 3745
Waifu : Kimo Force

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:42 am

Jesse wrote:
Call of Duty 4 is Infinity Ward's only descent creation. If you've ever played it that is.
Now now, MW2 and MW3 both had a fun campaign which I enjoyed so very much.



EW: also wtf does SJW stand for? Stupid Jealous Woman?
Ryuuji Takasu: looks cute. but cute sounds girly. so ill say kawaii
Lesbihonest: damn kimo you have the sexiest male voice ive ever heard o.o
Rika Furude: no, that wasnt ripped from the Bible or something, it's one of Rika Furude's poems in Higurashi. Deep ****.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:48 am

Yes, the campaign in both of those games were made fairly well. The multiplayer in those games need some serious attention though.


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Exiled
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Posts : 16
Reputation : 20

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 9:50 am

Both are good games, leave it at that


Quote :
VantageSP: my bro knocks on my door as I am watching MLP
VantageSP: I panicked and shut the TV off
VantageSP: prob thought I was watching porn

Quote :
Carmine "TheVoid" Napoli: Ive had sex with Chey
Carmine "TheVoid" Napoli: Shes... well...
Carmine "TheVoid" Napoli: I cant say shes tight.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 9:59 am

We're discussing our opinions about these two games. Is that making you mad?


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Supasmash
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 7
Posts : 510
Reputation : 582

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 1:57 pm

[REDACTED]



Sigs from friends! c:
Spoiler:
 



Last edited by Supasmash on Tue Oct 18, 2016 5:59 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 2:36 pm

I see the opposite from your statement. We're also just sharing our opinions to each other. Not exactly comparing them. I rarely see people play BF3 hardcore. The game that pisses people off the most is the one that people play hardcore. (aka MW3) It's so easy to get kills that people play it hardcore. It's a lot harder to get kills in BF3 if you're far away with an automatic gun. So people only get around 10-15 in a regular TDM. When people play CoD hardcore they tend to get anywhere from 20-30.


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fish
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 3054
Reputation : 3329
Waifu : Meheheh

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 8:34 pm

I have to agree with Jesse. CoD is a good game and BF3 is a great game.

In my opinion, CoD is only so successful because of CoD4. That game was ahead of its time compared to every other game at the time, and although there were bad points, there was nothing better.

Had BF3 come out in that time, BF3 would probably have taken away at least half of CoD fanbase. However, because CoD was so good and easy etc., it has attracted a whole load of non-gamers that now have the nerve to call themselves casual gamers who back away from anything that isn't their knowing loved CoD. Had BF3 been around with CoD4, CoD would be accepted as a much worse game, in my opinion. However, all of these "CoDFags", as they're known as, will literally only play CoD and then take every bad point of every other game out of proportion and play nothing but CoD.
The only reason MW3 has any footing against BF3 is the fact that so many CoD Addicts who have never played BF3 shout it sucks because it isn't part of their CoD series.

This is what happened with Skyrim. Skyrim is a brilliant game and as such, a whole load of people have simply become obsessed with it. These people now say "I've played and won Skyrim on Easy version! I'M A FANTASY GAMER!", and when anybody says anything to do with fantasy, they shout skyrim. An example of this would be in a recent post a guy talked about "freeform fantasies", which means, not skyrim. Then somebody shouts skyrim, because of the word fantasy.
And the same with Minecraft. I played Minecraft, I built a small hut, I'm a retro gamer.

I also have to disagree with Supasmash, both games were created to sell. Your game doesn't sell if you only attract hardcore gamers. There are easy, chilled team deathmatch modes on both games, and there are hardcore style modes on both games. Same with their campaigns. Though the CoD campaign on the hardest difficulty is still very, very easy, because of all teh CoDFags who get angry if somebody denies them their right to feel pro at a single game in which everybody feels pro.

Not that I'm slandering CoD, as I say, it's a good game. I'm quite good at it myself.
Then again, everybody is.











❑ Single
❑ Taken
✔ Mentally dating a character that doesn't actually exist.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Katarina
Archfiend Empress
 Archfiend Empress
avatar

Achievement Points : 58
Posts : 1189
Reputation : 1435
Waifu : Prinzessin Kitty

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 10:58 pm

i played bf3, i am like lvl 37 >_> i just unlocked DAO but last time i played was when i bought mw3..so yea..and i admit, i was addicted like hell to it..but mw3 is my style of gaming so i prefer mw3 and no offense to bf3 its a great game, except bazooka's do crappy damage :P (im pretty pro with it cuz i know how the gravity works)




Back to top Go down
View user profile
Jesse
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 46
Reputation : 58
Waifu : ItzJesse

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:52 pm

The RPG in BF3 is extremely terrible! You can destroy part of a building with it, but you can't kill someone in one shot with it. Also, I rarely see any lag in BF3! If only CoD was like that....


White Dawn of the Fallen Heroes.

" I feel colorless..... "
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Destined777
Mirage Knight
Mirage Knight
avatar

Achievement Points : 52
Posts : 854
Reputation : 1039
Waifu : Shido_Fuyuki

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Mon Feb 13, 2012 4:37 am

I have only played the beta of the BF3 and have played COD since #4.
But I guess it's saying something that I am still talking about BF3 just by only playing the beta.
I loved the team based and tactics needed for BF3 despite COD being able to Lone wolf an entire game.
But I think I am going to stick with COD since it's the one I have been playing plus most of my friends seem to always get COD never much BF so ye.




Back to top Go down
View user profile
Bakura Normal
Fangless Vampire
 Fangless Vampire
avatar

Achievement Points : 12
Posts : 1348
Reputation : 1664
Waifu : Bakura normal

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Tue Feb 14, 2012 1:51 am

crap games imo, mw2 was much better than 3,

bf i never got into, played the story mode, some online but never really got into it


i think mw would be much better if they make something more original, right now mw3 is just a shadow of mw2 with a diffrent name and diffrent maps witch are worse.


so overall:

not voting either.


Spoiler:
 
Back to top Go down
View user profile
AsianShadow
WDA Member
WDA Member
avatar

Achievement Points : 13
Posts : 1467
Reputation : 1711
Waifu : ProdigyShadow

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Tue Feb 14, 2012 11:44 am

bakura normal wrote:
crap games imo, mw2 was much better than 3,

bf i never got into, played the story mode, some online but never really got into it


i think mw would be much better if they make something more original, right now mw3 is just a shadow of mw2 with a diffrent name and diffrent maps witch are worse.


so overall:

not voting either.
Haha,yeah it sorta was but stupid hackers made the game garbage :(


~Those who never fail are those who never try.~


Spoiler:
 
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Fish
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
avatar

Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 3054
Reputation : 3329
Waifu : Meheheh

PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   Sun Feb 19, 2012 10:11 pm

Having played CoD I have figured a number of things that make the game suck.

Long story short, it panders to idiots. The majority of content in the game is based on making people who are stupid feel pro and feel like pro gamers.

Things that suck:

The community.
I played 6 to 9 games, recieved 1 hacker accusation and heard 4 people shouting "noob camper" and "noob akimo l2p". Each. I told one girl to stfu and play and she friend requested me on steam. Like, seriously? Really? That's the amount of conversation you need to have on CoD to qualify as friends?

Shotguns.
Every damn time I play, the shotguns piss me off. It's either instakill or 0 damage. Just because a shotgun is created for short range instances does not mean it is does not hurt at medium to long range. It is designed to clear houses with; some houses are pretty damn big and some houses have pretty damn big gardens. Play battlefield 3, on hardcore, and when clearing the Arms Dealer's house somewhat towards the end of the game, there will be a high chance of being instakilled by a shotgun from across the room. That is how it should be.

Absolute complete total inbuilt imbalance.
You'll spend 5 minutes running around to shoot guys in the back; get a killstreak of 4 shooting each guy ten times to kill them. Then one guy will turn around, aim at you, fire off 3 shots in a split second (literally. it's a gun that fires in 3-round bursts) and will kill you instantly at medium range. It takes 4 shots (or a double tap) to kill you with it at long range.

The ability your team has to mess up any and every.
You can, as I say, spend 5 minutes running behind your enemies, but then your teammate will throw an errant, random stun grenade, blast your face off, and you'll be slaughtered by a mass of outraged CoDplayers. They'll run in front of you and distract you during a maneuver, and they'll push you out of the way running through doors. When roughly 80% of your community is made up of idiots, and they have this much say over, well, the effectiveness of what you're doing, you're screwed.

Running off from InfinityWard's hatred of shotguns is my outrage at their treatment of sniper rifles.
I played the game for about an hour to an hour and a half, and saw most maps. I saw not one single sniper map. So, inkeeping with my MW1 traditions, I used a sniper rifle anyway. And I was horrified to find out that I couldn't get a single kill with one. Every time I'd hit somebody, it would hit them and they'd run off and I'd be left there cocking my rifle again thinking, "Well, if a sniper doesn't kill a guy in one hit, wtf is the point of having a sniper rifle?"
May as well snipe with a rocket launcher.

The difficulty and ease of killing people.
This is completely goddamn errant as well. See a guy at medium range and you can kill him in 4 or 5 hits from my gun, which, by the way, is the first one you get custom (The M4A1). Whereas if you see him running by you can fire in a straight line and he'll take about 10 hits running through the line of death but he won't die. And the same goes for melee instances. Since when did people using a knife become superman temporarily? It's like you can fire millions of shots into their chest, they'll speed through it faster than a plane and stab you in the face, shrugging off the mess you just made of their internal organs.

As stated above, the complete ease at which new players can rape faces of others.
I had never played MW3 before on the computer. I'd played two games previously on the xbox. I log into the computer and in the space of 6 games I'm rank 15, top of the leaderboards, 24 kills to 13 deaths. Using the first gun you get. I was unlocking about 3 guns every game.

Enemy retardation.
I mean, I know it's stupid to complain about people being TOO easy, but here's an example of something that happened to me. I ran around the outside of a map and flanked the enemy. I aimed at a window and started firing at a guy in this window. Then, 4 of his teammates go WHEEEEE! and run RIGHT through the bullets. I gain multikill, instant 5-kill killstreak reward. So I reload, and DO IT AGAIN. Triple kill. Nobody even tried to kill me. I just stood there and fired in a straight line and let people walk into it like razor wire. And if they're beating us in other games, well, your team are probably pretty stupid too.

General player denial of speed/skill/brains/common sense.
"Nice wallhack, Jwartz."
"fwish aimbot" (Fwish. That's me. I lol'd.)
"xarity camper"
"akimbo noob l2p"
"camping team noobs"

Those are just some of the catcalls I heard when playing the game. Akimbos are damn hard to aim with. Camping takes alot of patience. Jwartz had a UAV recon. I'm a fast aimer and I'm known to be a faster aimer.
Need I say more?

Ingame pointlessness.
Why have a killcam and why make you wait to spawn when you can literally just press F and spawn instantly? Spawntimes function to stop people running in like idiots which is what half the CoD population do.

Spawnkilling.
I got spawnkilled about 10 times. It's way too easy. At one point I actually got spawned in enemy fire, with a bullet in my face. Let's do th- SPLAT.

So, what would I rate this game out of ten? Well, 1 being lowest, 10 being highest, I give CoD's multiplayer mode an 8/10.

And now, your brow furrows and you scroll up to re-read what I said and try to find the positive part of the review. Well, here's my main reason for the 8: It's fun. In fact, only the obligation to populate my TF2 server made me stop playing the game.

Yes, the game makes mistakes, but everything (everything.) they have done has been to make the game fun to play for the majority of the gaming population. The community is huge and it tries to get all of the idiots, which are indeed the majority. Shotguns would make people rage if you could snipe with them; idiots believe shotguns work only as well as they do in CoD anyway. Players enjoy the feeling that grenades are realistic enough to work on their own team as well. Knifing people is fun and impossible if you just die every time you get hit in the chest, and most people tend to enjoy playing assault rifle and SMG classes more than sniper classes. New players like being able to own the older players.

Generally the game is a feel-good experience that makes you rage while you have inane fun. I honestly can't hold it against the makers of the game for making the game so fun, at the expense of pro gamers, because that's the way to give a huge fanbase alot of enjoyment, and that's the way they're getting REALLY damn rich.

Sorry pro gamers, they did this at your expense. As I say, personally I can't blame the IW, Activision or Sledgehammer, or Pegi, for not pandering to the minority.

It's a fun game with a load of flaws that make it so fun, and a great game style, setting and system for both fun and pro games anyway.

But BF3 is still better.











❑ Single
❑ Taken
✔ Mentally dating a character that doesn't actually exist.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Sponsored content




PostSubject: Re: MW3 vs Battlefield 3   

Back to top Go down
 
MW3 vs Battlefield 3
View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
World Dueling Academy :: Games :: Casual Gaming-
Jump to: